Speaking recently at the International Conference on Financing for Development,
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development Secretary-General, Angel
Gurría stressed the important role played by taxation in this area, somewhat
unsurprisingly, given the Organisation's traditional stance on all matters tax-related.
He told those attending the conference that:
"One of the challenges we face relates precisely to the degree to which
the world economy has become integrated. This makes it very difficult to talk
about 'mobilising domestic financial resources' without also talking about 'international
trade', or about 'international resources' without also discussing 'coherence'."
And continued:
"On the face of it, taxation and domestic resource mobilisation might
be low on the list of priorities, given the current crisis. However, even in
these difficult times I see three compelling reasons for putting taxation at
the centre of the domestic financial resource agenda."
"First, taxes provide the long term financial platform for sustainable
development. Taxes are the lifeblood of state services."
"Second, taxation matters for effective state-building. Bargaining between
governments and taxpayers plays a central role in the emergence of democratic
governance. Citizens want more responsive government. They want the state to
be accountable for its actions or inaction and taxes are the vital link between
governments and societies. Improved tax relationships between state, businesses
and society have provided a strong underpinning for broad-based growth and state
accountability in East Asia, for example."
"I am not arguing for tax hikes across the developing world. How and from
whom tax is raised matters, not just how much. One can easily imagine that a
broad-based but low rate tax system is effective in resource terms. And a simple,
fair and transparent system that operates with broad social consensus is important
for good governance and compliance."
"Third, taxation combined with economic growth is the antidote to long
term reliance on aid. As my friend Trevor Manuel has famously said, the correct
spelling of the word ‘aid’ is ‘T-A-X’."
Mr Gurria went on to suggest that there is a need to be realistic about the
challenges, as poor countries often lack the resources and capacity to build
effective tax collection systems, and developing the institutions and the human
capacity to implement tax policy in a way which enables transparency and certainty
is often challenging, and is often threatened by corruption.
He observed that:
"It may also be difficult to collect taxes from low income, agrarian economies
with large informal sectors, and to avoid coercion, especially at local level.
Moreover, the poor often already pay an equivalent of tax in the form of bribes
and informal fees."
"Citizens may be unwilling to pay tax, if they perceive unfairness in
taxation through special exemptions (such ‘tax expenditures’ are
very high in Latin America for example) and/or partial implementation. They
also have, or believe to have a clear perspective of use or misuse of public
funds. The degree of fiscal legitimacy directly reflects the confidence that
the people show in their government’s performance in collecting and spending
tax revenue. The credibility of the tax system suffers when expenditure is regressive
and widens rather than narrows the gap between rich and poor."
"The role of taxation as an agent of equality and fairness is critical.
There is a direct relationship between the quality of expenditure and the readiness
of citizens to meet their tax obligations. Hence, expenditure must be better
targeted to improve access to services like water and sewerage, health care
and education, for the broad population base."
The OECD chief went on to take a – not entirely unexpected – pot-shot at
offshore finance centres, which he dubbed 'tax havens', arguing that:
"Tax havens deprive governments of revenues needed for hospitals, schools
and roads, forcing bonafide taxpayers to pick up the tab. This applies as much
for developing countries as for developed ones. If developing countries are
to take firm action to stop this loss of revenue and make the most effective
use of their domestic financial resources for development, then they must have
the tools to protect their tax bases from capital flight and international tax
evasion. (And let me commend the UN, with assistance from countries such as
France, Germany, Norway and South Africa, for putting the issue at the centre
of our discussion over the next two days)."
He further claimed that:
"The OECD has developed standards of transparency and exchange of information
that have been universally accepted. The implementation of these standards will
allow developing countries to improve taxation of their own residents’
income not only in respect of undeclared foreign assets but also of domestic
assets, since they reduce the attraction of shifting assets abroad. At the same
time, it will force offshore financial centres to compete on the basis of services
provided rather than secrecy offered."
Returning to domestic tax issues within developing countries, Gurria stated
that:
"Change in developing countries will only come when driven by people in
developing countries. There is an example of a landmark initiative which deserves
donor support. The African Tax Administration Forum is currently being developed
by a Steering Group of African Tax Commissioners from Botswana, Cameroon, Ghana,
Nigeria, Rwanda, South Africa, and Uganda. It is African led, based on African
assessments of African needs. It arose out of a meeting of 30 African Tax Commissioners
with OECD officials, sponsored by OECD donors and the African Development Bank,
which took place in Pretoria last August."
And suggesting a way forward, the OECD chief argued that:
"We need to develop a renewed focus on enhancing domestic revenues through
broadly-based taxation, alongside higher aid flows at least in the medium term.
Experience shows that this will both increase and enable greater predictability
of revenues. It will also help ensure that aid-funded investments are sustainable,
and prepare for gradual exit from aid in the long term."
"Promoting demands in civil society for fair and transparent tax services
strengthens the practical relationship between state and society. Support by
donors for the development of a new Taxpayers Association in Kenya has had promising
results."
He added:
"We need to help countries retain and tax the profits attributable to
them from multinationals, to increase transparency and to implement internationally
agreed standards on exchange of information to counter tax evasion and other
abuses."
"We need to expand co-operation between international organizations active
in the tax area particularly the UN Committee of Tax Experts, the IMF, World
Bank and the OECD itself to enable us to work together with developing countries
to improve tax policy and revenue administration, which will diminish reliance
on aid in an uncertain climate."