In
a statement clearly designed
to influence proceedings at this week's ACEC hearings in San Francisco,
a White House spokesman who refused to be named, said last Friday
that the Clinton Administration supports a ban on internet access
taxes but favours a simplified sales tax structure for e-commerce
transactions. The spokesman also said that the Clinton administration
favours a moratorium on international taxes on electronic transmission.
The low key statement
is the first reaction from the White House to the flurry of internet
tax plans that have been touted over recent weeks in preparation
for this week's ACEC hearings. The most prominent of these plans
are Virginia Governor and ACEC Chairman James Gilmore's plan to
exempt online purchases from sales taxes and Utah Governor and
ACEC Member Mike Leavitt's plan to collect sales tax via 'trusted
third parties', which is also backed by the National Governors
Association.
The Clinton aide
who made the statement to the media described the Gilmore
plan as 'troubling', saying that with the Internet in its infancy,
this isn't the time to radically alter tax policy. Instead the
Clinton aide suggested that ACEC should 'carefully examine' the
Leavitt plan to simplify sales tax collection, although he did
concede that there were legitimate privacy concerns that would
need to be addressed in order for it to have a chance of being
adopted.
The White House
criticised the Gilmore plan on the basis that it would initially
provide online merchants with an unfair advantage and could eventually
also encourage 'bricks and mortar' retailers to avoid sales tax
by using in-store Internet kiosks to process purchases in order
to compete.
But the Clinton
Aid also warned States that it was too early to start collecting
sales taxes on internet transactions as a "real consensus" would
first be required on how to simplify the collection of tax across
America's 7,500 different tax jurisdictions.
In response to
the White House comments, a spokesman for Governor Gilmore
Miner said the Clinton administration "appears to be misinformed"
about the Governor's policies, as it only proposed to ban taxes
on remote e-commerce transactions facilitated by the internet,
thus preventing retailers from using in-store e-commerce kiosks
to avoid local sales tax.