Observers have suggested that although Vivendi Universal's decision to settle
with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) over claims that the company
issued false statements, made improper adjustments to earnings, and failed to
properly disclose its financial commitments, is unlikely to represent the end
of Vivendi's legal woes, it does represent a significant step forward.
In a statement released on December 23rd, the SEC announced that it had filed
and simultaneously settled a civil fraud action against Vivendi Universal, SA
(Vivendi), its former CEO, Jean-Marie Messier (Messier), and its former CFO,
Guillaume Hannezo (Hannezo).
The settlements included Vivendi's consent to pay a $50 million civil money
penalty, Messier's agreement to relinquish his claims to a EUR21 million severance
package that he negotiated just before he resigned his positions at Vivendi,
and payment of disgorgement and civil penalties by Messier and Hannezo that
total over $1 million.
The Commission revealed its intention to direct that disgorgement and penalties
paid in this case be paid to defrauded investors, including those who held Vivendi's
ordinary shares and its American Depository Shares during the time period alleged
in the Commission's complaint, pursuant to Section 308(a), the Fair Funds provision
of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002.
Linda Thomsen, Deputy Director of the Commission's Division of Enforcement,
observed that:
"This case shows the Commission's ongoing commitment to enforcing the disclosure
obligations of issuers and it shows our successful use of a new enforcement
tool provided by the Sarbanes-Oxley Act."
The firm now faces a class action in the United States and possible penalties
from France's market authorities. An investigation into Vivendi Universal conducted
by the Paris public prosecutor is ongoing.