The US Treasury Department has this week sent to Congress a Congressionally mandated report
on three international tax issues.
The "Report to the Congress on Earnings Stripping, Transfer Pricing and
US Income Tax Treaties" describes current issues regarding US earnings
stripping rules, transfer pricing rules, and the 'misuse' of income tax treaties
to which the United States is a party.
The report provided the following conclusions and recommendations in each of
the three areas studied:
Study on Earnings Stripping
The focus of the earnings-stripping study is on excessive payments of deductible
interest by foreign-controlled US corporations to related persons in whose hands
that interest is partially or fully exempt from US tax . While the study notes
that it is not possible to quantify accurately the extent of earnings stripping
generally, strong evidence exists of earnings stripping by foreign-controlled
domestic corporations that have undergone so-called "inversion" transactions,
in which the US parent company of a multinational corporate group is replaced
with a foreign parent in a low-tax or no-tax country.
The study did not find conclusive evidence of earnings stripping by foreign-controlled
domestic corporations that had not inverted. More information is needed to reach
a definitive conclusion on that issue. In order to obtain this additional information
and to further the administration of the current earnings stripping rules, the
study recommends that the relevant tax forms be modified to require more information
about earnings stripping. The IRS has already released a new proposed form.
Study on Transfer Pricing
The transfer pricing study focuses on issues relating to the shifting of income
from the United States through transactions between related parties. The study
reviews Treasury regulatory guidance under Internal Revenue Code section 482
and the effectiveness of current transfer-pricing rules and compliance efforts
to ensure that related-party transactions cannot be used to shift income out
of the United States improperly.
The study indicates that the transfer pricing rules must be continually monitored
to ensure their relevance to changing business conditions and to prevent income
shifting from non-arm's length transfer pricing. The study recommends that the
Treasury Department modernize and finalize three sets of transfer-pricing guidance.
More specifically, the study recommends:
- Cost Sharing: Revision of the existing guidance on contributions for which
arm's length consideration ("buy-in" payments) must be provided
as a condition to entering into a cost sharing arrangement;
- Services: Completion of the related-party services regulations to reflect
legal, business and economic developments since the regulations were issued
in 1968; and
- Global Dealing: Completion of new rules to allow taxpayers to determine
the amount of income from a global dealing operation that is subject to tax
in the United States, as well as the source of such income and the circumstances
under which such income is effectively connected with a US trade or business.
Study on US Income Tax Treaties
The study on US income tax treaties focuses on the need to prevent third-country
residents from inappropriately obtaining the benefits of US income tax treaties,
in particular by achieving inappropriate reductions in US withholding taxes.
The study notes that in recent years interest payments have surged from foreign-controlled
US corporations to related parties in countries that are a party to a US tax
treaty with no "limitation on benefits" (LOB) provisions and that
provides significant reductions in withholding rates. Such exploitation of those
treaties without anti-treaty shopping protections confirms, according to the report, that: (1) the LOB provisions
in other US agreements appear to provide significant deterrence against abuse,
and (2) the Treasury Department must continue its ongoing efforts to revise
treaties with no or inadequate LOB provisions.