European Union finance ministers
meeting in Brussels last week were unable to resolve the current
impasse over the proposed EU withholding tax which Britain is
vehemently opposing on the basis that it will substantially damage
London's £3 trillion ($4.7 trillion) international bond
market.
The already bitter dispute
took a turn for the worse when Britain threatened to use its veto
to block further progress on the EU's two-year old code of conduct
against harmful corporate tax practices, which the EU insists
must be passed as a whole package. Apart from addressing harmful
tax practices the code of conduct is also an important part of
plans to deregulate and harmonise EU financial markets.
According to John Palmer,
director of the European Policy Centre in Brussels the Code is
" an essential part of completing the level playing field of the
single internal market" and "a building block for the `E' part
of EMU".
Following the meeting British
Chancellor Gordon Brown added fuel to the fire by claiming
victory on the withholding tax debate. 'We are winning the argument.
We will continue to talk constructively but we will not agree
to anything that is against the British national economic interest
or that would put at risk the competitiveness of Europe or jobs
within Europe.'
Brown's comments drew angry responses,
particularly from the Finnish EU Presidency and German Chancellor
Gerhard Schroeder who was scathing: "Negotiations on the taxation
of interest income have been blocked by the intransigent behaviour
of one member state," Schroeder said. "I make no secret of the
fact that I have little understanding for such blockade tactics
that place national interest above necessary European solidarity.
"This policy is damaging to Europe and, over the longer term,
their own interests."
Finland tried unsuccessfully to
introduce a compromise deal with a greater emphasis on disclosure
as a means of combating tax evasion, but this was met with stubborn
resistance by Britain. The Finnish compromise would reduce the
cost of administering the tax by allowing agents to verify investors'
claims of non-EU residence based on national identification procedures
which would later be replaced by European standards.
Finland has now all but abandoned
any hope of brokering a deal with Britain at next month’s Helsinki
summit.