In
a move to clamp down on the offshore exodus of the UK betting
industry, the UK Treasury announced in this week's green budget
that it will introduce a ban on the advertising of gambling in
teletext and other electronic media. The move comes in response
to the recent high court win by Victor Chandler International
in which it was ruled that advertising via teletext is legal,
despite the fact that conventional advertising of (offshore) gambling
is illegal in the UK.
The move
offshore by Victor Chandler prompted the UK's big three betting
companies (Ladbrokes, Coral and William Hill) to also look overseas.
Ladbrokes has already started offering a Gibraltar-based service
and Coral and Hill are likely to follow soon. Also appearing on
the scene from offshore locations are new internet bookmakers
such as Sportingbet (Alderney) and Eurobet (Gibraltar) which offer
free bets with no tax or charges.
The UK
treasury is very concerned that it may lose a large portion
of the £500 million sterling it gets from betting duty to telephone
and internet betting services targeting the UK from offshore centres
such as Gibraltar and the Channel Isles. Telephone bets make up
13 per cent of the UK betting market and this figure is rising
by 20 per cent a year. A wholesale shift offshore of telephone
betting could potentially affect 35,000 UK jobs.
Chancellor
Gordon Brown said last week that no option had been ruled
out 'to discourage offshore betting and protect revenue' and suggested
that 'other measures' could be introduced in the Budget next March.
It is known that the UK Treasury is considering various other
possibilities, including the levying of taxes on telephone calls
to offshore centres, and an extension of the law used to recover
corporation tax from controlled overseas companies. Then there
is the EU-inspired initiative to force low tax jurisdictions to
bring their taxes into line with high-tax countries to eliminate
'unfair tax competition'.
The Government
of Alderney, where internet bookmaker Sportingbet is located,
reacted to the announcement by saying that it does not feel threatened.
Alderney Policy and Finance Committee Chairman Phillip Cranford-Smith
said 'They might be able to do it in Gibraltar; but Gibraltar
is part of the EU and we are not. As far as I know, the British
government is not in a position to exercise its powers in our
jurisdiction unless we step outside the bounds of good government.
We are not doing that'.
Although
e-commerce tax is fast becoming a thorny international issue
for high tax countries, the UK government believes it is prepared
for it. 'In the long term we are concerned but we are confident
that we can handle the Internet and are looking at establishing
international agreements through the OECD and EU to ensure tax
revenue continues,' said a Treasury spokesperson.
The Government's
attempt to clamp down on the betting industry is likely to
be part of a broader agenda to discourage other online services
such as share trading and publishing from relocating to offshore
tax havens.
Gambling
is only one of many services that can be delivered by telephone
or over the internet, and with increasingly cheap access, the
betting industry serves as a model of success for other services
that are subject to above average taxes by international standards.
In particular, there is concern that if a European Stock Exchange
is formed then companies could avoid stamp duty by reincorporating
in offshore jurisdictions in the European Union but still retaining
the advantages of their London listing.
The Treasury's
inevitable attempts to preserve its revenue base are at odds
with the Government's declared committment to e-commerce. Taxing
offshore phone calls, indeed! Tony and Gordon will no doubt have
many lively discussions on this subject over the garden fence
behind Nos. 10 and 11 Downing Street in the months to come.