The head of the Swiss Bankers
Association, Urs Roth, hit back last week at critics who have suggested that
Switzerland is a haven for tax evaders and money launderers, explaining that
the majority of accusations come from a fundamental misunderstanding of Swiss
banking secrecy rules.
According to Mr Roth for
many, the distinctions between money laundering, tax fraud, and tax evasion
are woefully vague. 'We want to maintain banking privacy,' he said, '[but] it
does not protect criminals, nor is the issue of the slightest relevence in the
pursuit of terrorists.'
Although the offshore jurisdiction
has come under fire of recent months, a great deal of assistance has been provided
by the Swiss banking sector in the hunt for terrorist assets, and Mr Roth believes
that the country has 'the strictest laws on the planet against money laundering,'
with wholly anonymous numbered accounts now banned under Switzerland's 'Know
Your Customer' regulations, and assistance readily provided by Swiss banks for
specific domestic and international investigations.
The fact that the Swiss
authorities will not tolerate 'fishing trips' by foreign governments has caused
many misunderstandings, particularly with countries such as France and Germany,
who would like the Swiss banking sector to furnish them with lists of their
citizens who save or invest offshore.
However, Mr Roth argues,
Switzerland has complied with all requests for information which it considers
legitimate and legal. 'There must be plausible suspicions,' he revealed. 'But
if we receive an executive order from the US government, we don't ask too many
questions- we regard this as sufficient grounds for checking our account data.'
According to Mr Roth, the
distinction between tax fraud and tax evasion is another controversial sticking
point. Tax evasion, although illegal in Switzerland, is an administrative, as
opposed to a criminal offense, for which banking secrecy rules cannot be lifted.
Tax fraud, where documents are forged, or other illegal actions taken in the
course of tax evasion activities, does warrant the removal of banking privacy
provisions.
'We have no sympathy for
tax evasion- every country tries to fight it,' explained Jacques de Watteville,
the head of the Swiss foreign ministry's financial and economic affairs department.
'But there is a balance to strike between tackling tax evasion and protecting
the private sphere.' And it would seem that public opinion is with him on this
issue- polls show that 80% of Swiss voters support the retention of banking
secrecy laws.