The Swiss government
hopes to scrap stamp duty on certain types of financial
transactions, in a move it says is necessary to maintain
the attractiveness of Switzerland as one of the world's
major financial centres. Earlier this week the Swiss
cabinet adopted an emergency decree to exempt certain
institutional investors from stamp duty on share deals
to stop more trading business moving to foreign exchanges,
in particular London. The finance ministry said it
was targeting investors such as private and public
sector investment funds, life insurers, pension funds
and domestic banks trading Swiss shares on markets
abroad.
The taxation of transactions
is a lucrative money-spinner for the Swiss administration,
and scrapping duty will result in a loss of some SFr500m
(US$290.7m) to the federal coffers. However, the proposals
now up for debate come are the Swiss government's
doing. They closely follow the recommendations of
a working group set up in March this year by the finance
minister, Kaspar Villiger.
There are clear worries
that foreign markets are syphoning off too much business
from Switzerland, with volumes of prominent Swiss
blue-chip shares traded abroad continuing to rise.
The Swiss Exchange (SWX) has said around 25 per cent
of total volume in these top-tier shares is traded
on the London Stock Exchange. Stamp duty amounts to
75 Swiss centimes per 1,000 Swiss francs worth of
traded volume. The SWX has said local brokers have
been paying the tax for clients to keep their business,
but the situation had to be overhauled.
The relief has also become
necessary in view of the planned cooperation between
the SWX and London-based electronic trading platform
Tradepoint Financial Networks and the resulting need
to harmonise British and Swiss taxation. The two equities
markets are setting up the virt-x trading platform
which is to include the SWX's blue chips.
The Swiss Bankers Association
(SBA) has rejoiced at the news of a potential cut
in duty, saying that the revision of the federal stamp
duty legislation was SFr500m "well invested".
This figure is about a quarter of the annual revenue
generated by federal stamp duty. SBA president Georg
Krayer said there were advantages to reducing the
tax burden on domestic and foreign pension funds,
insurance providers, investment fund companies and
the public sector. He commented: 'In this way, we
can make institutional business a rapidly growing
global market a second key pillar of the Swiss
asset management industry alongside private banking.'
He refuted claims that doing away with stamp duty
was a gift to the banks or the rich, saying: 'If Swiss
shares are to be sold in Switzerland, then Swiss market
players must be able to operate from their registered
offices in Switzerland on an even playing field with
their foreign competitors.'
The government has said
that full abolition of the stamp duty on financial
transactions if out of the question unless alternatives
are found to compensate for the lost revenue. The
emergency decree is to be debated in parliament later
in December before it takes effect.