Russian Telecommunications Minister Leonid Reiman, a close ally of President
Vladimir Putin, has found himself at the centre of a financial scandal over
allegations that he has attempted to illegitimately increase his ownership in
a Russian mobile operator through an offshore fund based in Bermuda.
In a ruling delivered on Monday, a Zurich Arbitration Tribunal concluded that
Reiman, known as "witness #7", was the only beneficiary of the Bermuda-based
IPOC fund and its option over a 25 percent stake in MegaFon, Russia's third
largest mobile operator.
LV Finance Group, which has been locked in a legal battle with IPOC for more
than three years, is disputing IPOC's claim that it has an option on a 25%
Megafon stake, in a complex case which has involved a string of associated shell
and associate companies and led to several suits and counter-suits in Switzerland,
Bermuda and the British Virgin Islands.
The current dispute is part of a wider battle between IPOC and Alpha Group,
an industrial holding firm which owns LV Finance Group. Alpha Group also owns
a 25% share in Russian mobile operator VimpelCom, a rival to MegaFon, which,
in 2004, became the recipient of a $158 million claim for back taxes in what
observers suggested at the time was a politically-motivated attack against Mikhail
Fridman, the billionaire tycoon who owns Alpha Group and who came into direct
conflict with Reiman when he acquired the MegaFon stake in 2003.
MegaFon's current shareholders are Swedish-Finnish TeliaSonera with 35.6%,
Russia's Telecominvest with 31.3%, CT-Mobile, fully owned by Alfa Group, with
25.1%, and IPOC with 8%.
In a statement issued late Monday, LV claimed that the tribunal supported its
accusations that payments on IPOC's stake option had been "criminally sourced,"
while the tribunal itself concluded that Reiman allowed his "personal enrichment"
to take precedence over the state assets which he, as a high-ranking public
official, had an obligation to protect.
Reiman, however, denies that he is the beneficiary of the IPOC fund and has
said that he was not invited either officially or unofficially to testify before
the tribunal.
The affair is being seen as a key test of President Putin's anti-corruption
drive, announced in his recent state of the nation address. Putin and Reiman
were close associates when the former was deputy mayor of St Petersburg and
the latter was on the board of a state-owned telecoms firm. Putin has also worked
for one of Reiman's companies.
IPOC expressed "surprise" at the tribunal's verdict, and indicated
that it would be prepared to appeal to the Swiss Supreme Court.
"We are also reviewing the damage and other issues left open for IPOC
to pursue under the just issued Award. This is just the latest stage in what
is an ongoing legal process," a spokesman said.