As the investigative spotlight in the United States focuses in on market timing
and late trading practices permitted by some mutual funds, a report published
by the Wall Street Journal this week has pointed to potential timing-related
pricing problems within the hedge fund industry itself.
According to the WSJ, the majority of hedge funds report on their performance
once a month, but because many invest in illiquid securities, it can take more
than a month to calculate and verify the relevant figures.
This can be something of an issue for hedge funds investing in other hedge
funds, which are obliged to wait until each underlying fund has reported its
results.
Although, as purchases and redemptions are only usually permitted a few times
a year, this reporting lag is unlikely to inconvenience investors. Virginia
Parker, president of Parker Global Strategies explained to the business daily
that many large investors insist that hedge fund managers impose a cut-off date.
This means that if the managers of the underlying funds have not reported their
returns by a certain date, the fund of hedge funds will be obliged to calculate
its performance based on the previous month's values.
The WSJ explained that:
"This can work to the advantage or disadvantage of investors buying in
or cashing out that month. If the late-reporting managers had a good month,
incoming investors buying shares based on the previous month's prices will be
getting a bargain, while outgoing investors are shortchanged. Likewise, if the
late reporting manager has had a bad month, incoming fund-of-hedge fund investors
may be paying too much for their shares, while outgoing fund-of-hedge fund investors
will escape the impact of the underlying manager's losses."
Although Ms Parker announced that she was not yet aware of any investors seeking
to trade rapidly in and out of funds of hedge funds in order to exploit stale
pricing situations, she suggested that the potential for abuse was certainly
there, and was likely to become of interest as the investigation into unfair
trading practices expands.