Despite the bad and worsening state of the country's finances, and a
decision last week to spend a $1.3bn privatisation proceeds fund on reducing
the $8.3bn national debt, Panama's President Mireya Moscoso has decided
to seek bids on preliminary work to modernize the Panama Canal.
The favored modernization proposal – building a third set of canal
locks – will cost an estimated $4 billion. In October, Economy Minister
Norberto Delgado said the Inter-American Development Bank would donate
$1 million for feasibility studies. The project also requires enlargement
of the Canal waterway, which could cost up to $500 million.
Work is scheduled to begin in early 2002, but government officials are
worried about the project’s total price tag. The Canal Authority
has yet to line up financing for the project, but intends to pay off the
new debt with canal toll revenues, which are expected to increase with
the additional traffic resulting from enlargement.
However, there is plenty of opposition to the project in Panama, with
some economists saying that it would take decades to earn back the cost
of renovation.. Many say there has not been adequate consultation, and
that viable alternatives have not been investigated. The Authority says
that 40% of ships using the Canal already exceed its design limits in
terms of size, and that by 2015 the Canal will be completely obsolete
if it isn’t modified.
The main environmental problem is that the vast quantities of additional
fresh water required to operate the new locks may flood large areas of
farmland, displacing up to 10,000 campesinos (country dwellers).
Law 44, on the books since 1999, allows the Authority to enlarge the
canal basin from 330,000 hectares to 552,000 hectares to create new reservoirs
by building dams, but 100,000 campesinos living in the area have formed
organizations to oppose the dams. They say they are not necessarily against
the project, but resent the lack of transparency in the Authority's handling
of it.
"We are concerned that, after so many years of struggle, the Canal
has not brought benefits to Panamanians," said opposition leader
Francisco Hernández, and points to some studies that allegedly
show the Canal could stay in business another 100 years without being
enlarged.