Despite the Asian Development Bank's (ADB) recent
recommendation that the Cook Islands' newly created Bank of Cook Islands (BCI)
should stay clear of commercial banking, the government has decided to push
the BCI into that arena. The ADB publicised the results of its review of the
BCI at a recent national economic forum and urged the BCI to stick 'predominantly'
to development funding and leave the 'safe' loans regarding housing and personal
loans to established commercial banks.
But the government's recent merger of its Savings
Bank and Development Bank into the BCI bringing deposits worth around $3 million
under one roof is likely to push the BCI into commercial banking.
BCI board chairman, Vaine Teokotai, responding
to Cook Islands' press comment that it is too risky for short-term deposits
to be used for development finance, said that a key reason for ignoring the
advice from the ADB is the bank's survival. He explained: 'the most essential
element of a bank's mission is economic sustainability.' He said that although
the government 'is not seeking the high returns expected of commercial banks
such as Westpac and ANZ', it is expecting the BCI to shoulder the cost of running
its banking services while maintaining its financial responsibilities and its
commercial interests would help the bank to meet these responsibilities.
Teokotai also raised concerns over the bank's
potential to miss out on commercial customers and he asks why BCI should pass
a 'good and profitable customer to the ANZ or Westpac who were not prepared
to assist from the beginning?' He added: 'why should the bank not also finance
the car and house of a good customer that has prospered from early development
support?'
In addition he said that funds could be invested
in offshore money markets for a slightly higher return, and that it 'seems sensible
to use these funds to finance a few commercial loans and house mortgages.'
The ADB is a multilateral development finance institution
that is dedicated to reducing poverty in Asia and the Pacific region. Established
in 1966 ADB is now owned by 59 member countries including the Cook Islands which
is the 40th largest shareholder. The ADB is a large and influential organisation
providing loans to fund projects and activities in its Asian and Pacific developing
member countries as well as furnishing them with several billion US dollars'
worth of contracts to procure goods and consulting services. Although the ADB
can only offer guidance to its member countries, it is likely that the BCI's
decision to go against the ADB and step into the arena of commercial banking
will lead to some disagreement between the two parties.