After Swissair's bankruptcy administrator, law firm Wenger Plattner, said
on Friday that parts of the company might be be put into liquidation today
unless a rescue plan is approved, frantic negotiations continued during
the weekend to find sufficient backers for the plan to save the airline,
known as 'Phoenix'.
There are still several different versions of Phoenix, but the most
likely one, Phoenix Plus, would see 52 Swissair jets, equal to two-thirds
of its fleet, transferred to Swissair's regional airline, Crossair. Phoenix
Plus would cost 9,400 jobs, or 14 per cent of Swissair's workforce, and
would require a total of SFr4bn of new equity, far more than the SFr1.5bn
originally thought to be needed when the airline collapsed three weeks
ago.
Although various lesser options have been canvassed, the Swiss government
and a number of major Swiss companies believe that Phoenix Plus is the
only realistic option if Switzerland is to maintain an intercontinental
airline and a matching hub at Zurich airport. In their eyes, the final
collapse of Swissair would have incalculable consequences not just for
Swiss pride in its image, but more directly in terms of collateral job
losses.
It is a moot point whether supporting the high-price, over-unionised
dinosaurs of Europe's antiquated airline industry is worth the effort
and the cost. In economic terms it probably isn't, but governments aren't
good at being economically numerate when it comes to national symbols
like Swissair.
The Swiss government, which injected SFr450m to keep Swissair flying
three weeks ago, is proposing to put up a further SFr500m of the SFr2bn
needed to increase Crossair's capitalisation, and will also fund Swissair's
continued operations until April 2002 when the transfers of the airline's
assets to Crossair would become legally effective.
Switzerland's top two banks, UBS and Credit Suisse, are still prepared
to take part in the rescue - they originally offered SFr1.5bn to the plan
- and they were joined on Friday by other major Swiss companies including
Nestlé, which reported internal sales growth of 4.2% in the nine
months to September, down from 4.6% at the half year, but ahead of its
4% target. (People who are afraid of flying stay at home eating more chocolate
instead, it seems.)
“We are identified as a Swiss company and we don’t want to
have Switzerland seen as a country where things do not work,” explained
a Nestlé spokesman. However the company said that it would only
consider investment in a viable airline that could yield a return for
shareholders. “There is no question of throwing good money after
bad,” said the spokesman. Nestlé's former chief financial
officer, Mario Corti, was asked to take over as Swissair chairman when
the company's financial emergency emerged in April.
Other Swiss multinationals, including the Roche and Novartis drug groups,
as well as Swatch and Zurich Financial Services, may take part. If the
deal is finalised, it is understood that former Credit Suisse chairman
Rainer Gut will chair a working party to oversee the metamorphosis of
Crossair into a major international carrier.
Between the Government and the private sector, then, it seems that the
SFr4bn may be achievable, although the timescale for complex negotiations
is very short. The attitude of the EU and Competition Commissioner Loyola
de Palacio to such a major injection of state funds into a national carrier
may be very influential in the decision. A private sector investor would
not want to be vulnerable to possible EU sanctions against a company that
had broken State Aid rules. Although Switzerland is not a member of the
EU, it has bilateral treaties with the EU which bind it in to large parts
of single market legislation.
The complication of the deal probably means that it can receive no more
than a general go-ahead today, and that may not be enough for the administrators.
Filippo Beck, head of the Wenger Plattner administration team says that
anything short of a 'guarantee' of new funding would increase pressure
on Wenger Plattner and the bankruptcy judge responsible for Swissair to
reject current proposals to grant it a "definitive debt-restructuring
moratorium", and instead put the company straight into liquidation.
Wenger Plattner says its primary obligation is to protect the interests
of Swissair's creditors, including its employees. Six Swissair companies
are currently under credit protection and under the administration of
Wenger Plattner: SAirGroup, SAirLines, Flightlease AG, Swissair Schweizerische
Luftvehrkehr AG, Swisscargo AG and Cargologic AG.