Ruling on Thursday, the European Court of Justice followed the opinion delivered
by Advocate General, Juliane Kokott in January of this year, sending a trademark
dispute between chocolate manufacturers, Nestle and Mars back to the UK courts.
Nestle had attempted to lay sole claim to the slogan "Have a Break", a phrase
used in conjunction with its Kit Kat bars, and in 1995 sought to register the
slogan for all of its products.
Rival firm Mars objected, however, and the UK authorities blocked the claim,
arguing that the phrase lacked an inherent or distinct character which would
allow it to be trademarked. Following Nestle's appeal, the UK asked the ECJ
to rule on the matter.
Ms Kokott announced earlier this year that the phrase had not acquired a sufficiently
"distinctive character" to be trademarked, despite its long association with
the Nestle product.
The ECJ supported this assertion, explaining that it could not, therefore,
approve Nestle's trademark application.
"It is for the national court to determine whether the mark ‘Have a Break’
has come to identify the product or service concerned," the ECJ announced
in a statement, continuing:
"In that context the Court points out that the relevant factors must be
assessed globally and, in the context of that assessment, the following items
may be taken into consideration: the market share held by the mark; how intensive,
geographically widespread and long-standing use of the mark has been; the amount
invested by the undertaking in promoting the mark; the proportion of the relevant
class of persons who, because of the mark, identify goods as originating from
a particular undertaking; and statements from chambers of commerce and industry
or other trade and professional associations."