An Ontario lawyer for Boaz Manor, co-founder of failed hedge fund Portus Alternative
Asset Management, said last week that Manor will fight allegations made against
him by the Ontario Securities Commission and return to Canada when necessary.
Lawyer Brian Greenspan said: "He intends, obviously, to defend and respond
to the charges and it's always been his intention to appear as required in answer
to any charges that are brought against him."
Last month, Portus's receiver KPMG said that Boaz Manor, who left Canada for
Israel in February after the collapse, had been ordered by an Israeli court
to remain in the country until he has been interviewed by KPMG investigators.
Fearing that Manor would leave Israel if he became aware of proceedings against
him, KPMG obtained the ex parte orders from Judge Judge H. Weinboum-Waletzky
of the Tel Aviv Court of Peace and Judge Magen Altuvia of the District Court
of Tel Aviv. KPMG also says that it had obtained a lien on up to $20.7 million
over Manor’s property in Israel, representing $3.1 million that Manor allegedly
transferred to his lawyer and $17.6 million missing from Portus's funds.
KPMG told an Ontario court earlier this month that it will again ask a Hong
Kong judge to order Manor's sister-in-law to answer questions again about diamonds
bought with Portus investors' money. Yu Jieying picked up $8.8 million worth
of diamonds, including a 22-carat gem, which Manor arranged to be purchased,
said KPMG lawyer John Finnigan. She had ignored a previous order to submit to
questioning on October 13th. "We're seeking remedies against her,"
Finnigan told Ontario Superior Court judge Colin Campbell.
Portus was put into receivership in March and in June KPMG won an Ontario court
order compelling Boaz Manor to account for all the money originating from the
now-insolvent hedge fund. Manor could face up to 15 years in prison if convicted
of the three counts of violating Ontario's securities act brought by the Securities
Commission, and a fine of $1 million fine per count. However, Michael Watson,
head of the OSC's enforcement branch, admitted that while it is possible to
try Manor in abstentia, he can't be forced to return to face the charges in
Ontario. "Most provincial statute offences would not be subject to extradition
and, in fact, most provincial statute offences - even if the person were here
- wouldn't be subject to arrest," Watson said.
The RCMP is also investigating the affair and may stand a better chance of
attacking Manor under Federal laws - but they were very slow to begin investigations
and there has been no news about their progress.
KPMG said in a recent court report that managers of defunct Canadian hedge
fund Portus skimmed up to 13% of assets; KPMG wants to make Portus bankrupt
in order to speed up distributions to the 26,000 cheated investors. The report
says that to date, about $662.15 million (Canadian) and about $37.2 million
(U.S.) have been found and secured in 130 Portus bank and investment accounts
in Canada, the Turks and Caicos and the Cayman Islands, out of more than $800m
that was collected.
The majority of Portus assets remain tied up in notes issued by France's Société
Générale which were purchased for $529m, and mature between 2008 and 2011.
Although most of the Portus assets have been identified and can be recovered,
it is thought that it will take years for investors to get their money back.
The Ontario Securities Commission is said to be preparing to attack some of
the 1,000 financial advisers who put their clients into Portus. Many of the
advisers concerned have said they are willing to return principal amounts to
investors, or return commissions to the receivers of Portus, KPMG, and Manulife
Securities International Ltd, which referred many clients to Portus, has guaranteed
the principal investments of those clients, providing C$40m in its accounts
for that purpose.
The OSC, however, is set to pursue advisers who may not have fulfilled their
'kyc' or know-your-client obligations when recommending Portus. Some 26,000
individual investors will lose money through the Portus affair, and many of
them are people who should never have entered such an investment, say regulators.