London-based Man Group Plc, the world's largest listed hedge fund manager, has
been ordered to hand over documents and other information, including telephone
records and audio recordings, to the receiver of a collapsed hedge fund, who
is investigating allegations that substantial trading losses were hidden from
investors.
Man Group subsidiary, Man Financial, which acted as broker to the now defunct
hedge fund Philadelphia Alternative Asset Management (PAAM), was accused in
a contempt motion filed in a Pennsylvania court in September by the court-appointed
receiver Clark Hodgson of complicity in helping PAAM to disguise the fund's
true investment performance by hiding $175 million in trading losses in a secret
account - losses which were not reported to investors.
Cayman-registered PAAM, set up and managed by former trader Paul Eustace, was
launched last year and raised some $300 million from investors. However, in
June of this year the fund collapsed.
The firm's assets, and the money remaining in its hedge funds, have been frozen
by the judge overseeing the case, which has been brought by the Commodity Futures
Trading Commission (CFTC).
Man Group has strenuously denied
allegations that it has failed to cooperate with the US authorities in the investigation,
and has stressed that it has already handed over more than 4,200 pages of documentation
to assist the receiver. However, this is seemingly not enough to satisfy Mr
Hodgson, who has demanded access to more than 10,000 documents supplied
by Man to the CFTC.
In its reply to the contempt motion, Man rejected the receiver's allegations
as "scandalous and prejudicial" and argued that Hodgson's demands
were "unreasonable, overly broad and unduly burdensome".