Earlier this week, the Maltese
Chamber of Commerce released its reponse to Finance Minister John Dalli's 2002
budget, in which it stated that although the general direction of the budget
was satisfactory and understandable given the current economic climate, too
little had been done in terms of corporate and individual income tax.
Amongst other things, the
Chamber called for greater transparency in the way in which the Finance Ministry
records transactions, the simplification of statutory requirements and fiscal
incentives for small enterprises and contractors, reforms to the financing of
the welfare and health sectors, the reorganisation of bodies entrusted with
attracting investment in the country, and greater private sector involvement
in state-run enterprises.
However, the Chamber of
Commerce's main concern was the adjustments made to the personal income tax
rates for married couples, which it felt did not go nearly far enough. In his
2002 budget, John Dalli raised the non-taxable income limit by Lm100 to Lm4,100,
increased the first tax bracket of 15% to Lm1,800, and raised the second tax
bracket of 25% by Lm500 to Lm2,500.
Although the COC recognised
that the country's budget deficit problem was paramount in the Finance Minister's
mind, and that the budget was primarily intended to stimulate economic growth,
it said that it: 'would have preferred to see a more radical change with a reduction
both in terms of personal and corporate taxation.'
It explained that: 'a lowering
of personal and corporate tax rates would serve to substantially increase revenue
from income tax particularly through the inclusion of underground economic operators
into the fiscal system.'
The leader of the opposition
Alternattiva Demokratika party, Dr Harry Vassallo, was somewhat less diplomatic
in his criticisms of the budget. Speaking in late November, he called Mr Dalli's
offering: 'a bland budget of mixed messages', and condemned the savings netted
as a result of the rate adjustment for married couples as 'insignificant'.