The US government’s ongoing effort to stamp out abusive tax sheltering
has suffered a setback, after a federal judge lifted a freeze on $500 million
worth of assets belonging to thousands of medical professionals in the Xelan
case.
The order, made by Judge Larry Burns in
San Diego's District Court on Friday, overturns a previous order by a federal judge on November
4, which froze the assets temporarily while the government pursued its case.
The case itself centres on the firm Xelan Inc and several related companies,
including the charitable Xelan Foundation and an insurance firm based in Barbados.
The IRS has accused the firm of selling illegal tax reduction schemes to around
4,000 doctors, who now face bills for back taxes, penalties and interest approaching
the $420 million mark.
IRS Commissioner Mark W. Everson recently described the case as “one
of the biggest cases we have seen in years” concerning illegal tax sheltering.
However, according to the New York Times, Judge Burns argued that the Justice
Department and the IRS have not yet proven that the group of companies related
to Xelan were selling questionable tax shelters, and that therefore it was inappropriate
to freeze any assets suspected to be connected to the abusive transactions.
The report revealed that the government intends nonetheless to press ahead with its case
against Xelan, which is in bankruptcy and is also the subject of a criminal investigation
by a federal grand jury.