A new survey by Deloitte of employee remuneration in enterprises with 10 or
more employees shows a wide divergence in average remuneration levels and social
security costs in 24 of the 25 EU member states.
The survey highlights that a wide gap still exists in the remuneration levels
of EU member states that joined in May 2004 and the original 15 members.
According to the survey, Lithuania has the lowest remuneration costs at just
over EUR5,100. Estonia and Slovenia are not far behind with remuneration levels
of EUR9,216 and EUR9,264. These figures represent a considerable increase over
the figures for 2005 which were EUR7,466 and EUR8,321 respectively.
Ireland is ranked 15th out of the 24 countries surveyed, with an average remuneration
cost of EUR36,852. In 2005 the figure was EUR34,997 – this represents
an increase of 5.3%. Deloitte observed that a positive aspect of Budget 2006 is that
for the second year in a row it has not added to the total cost of employment,
while at the same time, it has reduced the total tax on the employee by EUR530.
However, the relative positions of the countries change when one compares
the employee tax and insurance costs as a proportion of the total remuneration
paid. Ireland continues to have the lowest level at 6.34% post-Budget, with Cyprus
in second place at 8.77%. This confirms Ireland as a low tax jurisdiction
for employees.
Also, when one compares the employer social insurance costs as a percentage
of remuneration, Ireland is in fifth position. Denmark has the lowest percentage
at 1.36%. Ireland, at 9.71%, is just behind Cyprus, Malta and the UK which have
percentages of approximately 9.1%.
Comparing the combined costs of tax and employee and employer social insurance
costs with the total cost of employment, Ireland post-Budget is found to have
the lowest percentage cost. This was only a marginal advantage in 2005, but the
gap between Ireland and Cyprus has increased to 1.44%. Malta and Luxembourg
continue to occupy third and fourth places respectively.
Commenting on the results of the survey, Pat Cullen, tax partner with Deloitte,
stated that:
“The survey shows the continued commitment of the Irish Government to
keep the tax and social welfare costs down and hence keep the costs of employment
down. However, Ireland continues to be exposed to pressures from eastern Europe
where employment costs are still relatively low. As those economies gather pace
and start to compete more effectively for international mobile investment, Ireland
will be at a considerable disadvantage.”
He added: “While it is unrealistic to expect Ireland to be able to close
the gap in remuneration levels, the challenge for Ireland Inc is to effectively
promote the added value that Ireland has to offer through its location, other
taxation measures and experienced workforce so that it continues to attract
sustainable investment to ensure its economic growth.”