Last week the Irish
Government published its 'Fairer All Round' document revealing
its £1.2 million budget proposals. The Fine Gael party spokesman
Mr Michael Noonan said that particular attention was paid to the
introduction of a new middle rate of tax at 33 per cent and that
the Government aimed to fulfil its commitment to reduce taxes:
'Fine Gael believes that tax reductions and improved public services
in exchange for wage increases are still the best strategy for
economic growth.'
The idea to focus
tax relief largely upon the low and middle-income earners, according
to Mr Noonan, would have less of an impact on inflation than tax
relief for the more wealthy tax-payers.
Further budget proposals
include the removal of the minimum wage from the tax net through
tax credits and increasing tax exemptions especially for pensioners.
Mr Noonan continued: 'Fine Gael believes that the removal of people
on the minimum wage from the tax net should be the primary income
tax objective. This should be achieved over two budgets. The use
of tax credits ensures that all taxpayers, and not only those
on the minimum wage, will benefit equally from this.'
There was also a
proposal to cut the VAT rate by 2 per cent which would bring it
down to 19 per cent. This would also lower the Consumer Price
Index and would be likely to lead to consumers deciding to temporarily
defer any expenditure plans. Mr Noonan said this was necessary
if the government was to support Ireland in becoming a major European
hub for e-commerce. To sell over the Internet the applicable VAT
rate is that in the country of origin - currently Ireland's rate
is 1.5 per cent above the EU average rate of 19.5 per cent.
As far as tax relief
was concerned Mr Noonan explained: 'Fine Gael has already proposed
that some of the income tax relief granted this year should be
paid through the allocation to taxpayers of interest-bearing bonds,
which would not be cashable for three years. Additional interest
would be paid to persons who held these bonds for longer than
three years.'
Minister of State
for Finance Mr Martin Cullen reacted to the budget proposals with
disappointment, he said: 'After three years of holding its breath,
Fine Gael has produced what amount to shortsighted, short-term
solutions which tinker at the edges of an issue that warrants
far wider analysis and consideration than Fine Gael appears to
realise.'
The budget proposals
coincide with a report circulated at an EU finance ministers'
meeting last week which revealed that the tax burden on the lower
paid in Ireland is one of the lowest in the world. Minister for
Finance Charles McCreevy enthused: 'we have done significantly
more to address low pay tax issues by cutting average and marginal
tax rates than nearly all [our] comparators.' He said that, compared
to the UK, a single person earning £9,000 pa pays an average
rate of 15 per cent whereas in Ireland the rate is significantly
lower at 8 per cent.
In terms of tax issues
this year has been an eventful one for Irish politics with a "pre-budget
controversy" that has taken place in the months leading up
to the December budget. In October, the Taoiseach, Mr Bertie Ahern,
said that he would prefer to widen tax bands and allowances instead
of reducing income tax rates but his opinion differs from that
of the Tanaiste, Ms Mary Harney, who favours a significant income
tax cuts approach.
The Irish Business
and Employers Confederation (IBEC) has also had much to say about
budget proposals in the past few weeks. It has adopted a firm
stance in demanding the retention of the higher income tax band
and this has led to a clash with Mary Harney who has made it clear
that she would like to see the 44 per cent rate lowered by declaring:
'it does not keep bright young people in Ireland if you have those
margins.'
In addition, Mr Ahern
has insisted in asserting the Irish government's right, without
being influenced by the EU, to remain responsible for the majority
of its public expenditure (particularly in regard to low taxation
issues) by stating in early November: 'In Ireland's case, low
tax rates have played a crucial role in creating our economic
success.' At his address to the Dublin South Central constituency
office, Mr Ahern concluded his speech with a pledge to ensure
that the government's next two budgets will bring about 'an historic
and irreversible social change.'