Irish Finance Minister Brian Cowen has announced further restrictions on controversial
tax reliefs which can be used by wealthy taxpayers and businesses to substantially
reduce their tax bills.
The new measures, announced as part of the 2007 budget, are being introduced
with effect from 1 January 2007 and will limit the use of these tax breaks by
those with high incomes.
The measures are based on restricting the amount of specified reliefs which
a person can use to reduce their tax bill in any one year to 50% of the person’s
income.
Under the new system, taxpayers will add up the total amount of specified reliefs
being claimed, which will be added back to the taxpayer’s taxable income to give
a “recomputed gross income” figure. Where the recomputed gross income
is greater than a high income threshold of EUR250,000, then the aggregate deduction
for specified reliefs in the year will be restricted to 50% of recomputed gross
income, Cowen said.
The new taxable income figure will be taxed at the ordinary income tax rates;
since the top rate of 42% will generally apply, an effective rate of close to
20% will be achieved.
The system will contain a taper to avoid a sudden jump in tax at the threshold,
and any relief denied in a particular year will be carried forward to the following
year.
The specified reliefs will be listed in the Finance Bill and will include the
property based incentive reliefs in general and various other reliefs, including
exemption of artistic income, but will exclude the normal items claimed by taxpayers
such as medical expenses, trade union subscriptions, exemptions such as that
for child benefit, as well as the normal business expenses and deductions for
capital allowances on plant and machinery.
It is estimated that the measure will yield EUR5 million in 2007 and EUR50
million in a full year.
Cowen also announced that a number of property-based tax incentive schemes
for businesses are to be discontinued, including: the Urban Renewal Scheme,
Rural Renewal Scheme, Town Renewal Scheme, and the special reliefs for hotels,
holiday cottages, student accommodation, multi-storey car parks, third-level
educational buildings, sports injury clinics, developments associated with park-and-ride
facilities, and the general rental refurbishment scheme.
Under transitional arrangements, full relief will be available for qualifying
expenditure up to end-December 2006; 75% of the normal relief will apply for
qualifying expenditure in the period January to end-December 2007; 50% of the
normal relief will apply for qualifying expenditure in the period January to
end-July 2008; and no relief under the schemes will apply for expenditure after
that date.
Cowen estimated that the closure of these tax relief schemes would save something
in the order of several hundred million euros annually, although these savings
will not be felt until 2012 when the bulk of existing capital allowances have
been fully claimed in tax returns.
The Finance Minister also said that he intends to introduce measures to restrict
interest relief on loans granted between companies in the same group to crack
down on the creation of artificial loans made with the sole intention of qualifying
for tax relief, known as Section 247 Relief.
The proposed restriction will apply to structures whereby indebtedness is created,
effectively between companies in a group, in connection with the transfer of
share ownership from one company to another company in that group. Cowen said
that such measures would be "carefully targeted" so as to minimise
the possible impact on legitimate commercial use of Section 247, or any other
area of the tax code.
The Section 247 restrictions will be brought forward in the 2006 Finance Bill
and will affect transactions made on or after 7 December 2005.