A report from the Institute of Employment
Rights (IER) has claimed to have evidence that the Inland Revenue has
promoted tax and national insurance evasion in the construction industry
by allowing building firms to falsely register directly employed workers
as self-employed.
In a press release from the IER, author
of the report, Dr Mark Harvey said: 'We have found disturbing evidence
that the Inland Revenue and the Contributions Agency have sanctioned large-scale
false self-employment by a consortium of 16 large contractors in London
and the South East Region.'
Entitled 'Undermining Construction: The Corrosive
Effects of False Self-Employment', Dr Harvey's report questions whether
the increase in the numbers classed as self-employed really reflects the
actual employment status of construction workers. It claims that false
self-employment in the industry is directly costing the exchequer between
£1.5 billion and £2 billion each year.
This, states the IER, amounts to a subsidy
from the tax payer to the construction industry of 2p in every pound;
it estimates that as many as 361,000 construction workers in Britain
are falsely registered as self-employed.
In response the Inland Revenue dismissed
the report's findings and denied allegations that it has encouraged
tax or National Insurance evasion of any kind. A spokesman said yesterday
(Monday): 'If the author has any evidence of tax evasion, he should contact
us directly.'
George Brumwell, General Secretary of the
Union of Construction, Allied Trades and Technicians (UCATT), which commissioned
the report, described false self-employment as being a scourge in the
construction industry for the last thirty years. He said: 'Employers have
used the current system to mis-categorise construction workers and deny
them their basic employment rights. The culture of lawlessness within
the industry has to be tackled.'
The report concluded by calling for a major
change in the law and tax regulations to eliminate false self-employment
in UK construction and to generate much needed income for public services.