The Isle of Man's Chief Minister Tony Brown is seeking clarification of the British government’s position following 'unfortunate' comments from Chancellor Alistair Darling, who recently described the island as a 'tax haven,' and suggested that it was time to review the relationship between the UK and the Isle of Man.
Mr Darling made the remarks on Monday when answering questions at the Treasury
Select Committee on the UK’s approach to Icelandic banks and the position
of depositors with Kaupthing Singer & Friedlander Isle of Man.
Brown said: "Alistair Darling’s comments were most unfortunate,
to say the least. He did not seem to be aware that the relationship between
the United Kingdom and the Isle of Man has already been reviewed, and that an
agreement reinforcing that relationship was signed by the Lord Chancellor on
behalf of the UK government in May last year.
He added: "Mr Darling made no mention either of the new tax co-operation agreements
signed between the Isle of Man and the UK just five weeks ago, on September
29."
The Chief Minister continued: "While Mr Darling appears to be in the dark
over this issue, the position of the Isle of Man government is clear. We are
not asking the UK for any favours, but they do have a constitutional responsibility
to represent us internationally. We have also pointed out, in support of depositors
with the local bank, that the closure of Kaupthing Singer & Friedlander
in the Isle of Man was the direct result of actions taken by the UK Government."
Darling told the committee that, in the light of the events surrounding the
Kaupthing Singer & Friedlander affair "we really do need to have a
long hard look about the relationship between this country (the UK) and the Isle of Man,
a tax haven sitting in the Irish Sea."
He added: "We can't have a situation where you have sitting there all
sorts of tax advantages accruing to being in the Isle of Man and when things
go wrong people then say what about the British compensation scheme. So it is
important that we take this opportunity, not rushing into it, not a knee-jerk
reaction… but I think we do need to have a look at it and indeed that
is something your committee might want to have a look at as well.”