The International Intellectual Property Alliance (IIPA) recently submitted
its recommendations to US Trade Representative Susan Schwab in its annual review
of copyright piracy and market access problems around the world.
The IIPA submission discusses copyright protection, enforcement, and market
access problems in 51 countries/territories, of which it recommended that 43
be placed on an appropriate USTR watch list.
The report also discussed piracy and market access problems in an additional
eight countries, but did not recommend that these countries be placed on any
formal list. Finally, the IIPA submission described key challenges and initiatives
that define the copyright industries’ trade agenda for 2008.
Commenting on this year’s Special 301 process, IIPA’s Eric H. Smith
noted that:
“The annual Special 301 process continues to be an important tool to
bring to the attention of our trading partners the importance of high levels
of protection for, and strong enforcement against piracy of, copyrighted works,
both to the U.S. economy and to the economies of these countries."
"US business and entertainment software, movies and home video entertainment,
music and recordings, and books and journals continue to be an important driver
of the US economy -- contributing almost 13% to US economic growth in 2005.”
This year’s submission in particular reflects the copyright industries’
grave concern with the explosive growth of
online and mobile piracy. To meet this challenge, IIPA members are pressing
for enhanced international norms, more effective and deterrent enforcement of
those norms, and greater global law enforcement cooperation.
Smith went on to add that:
“Canada joins China and Russia this year as countries of the greatest
concern to the copyright industries. While there have been a few positive developments
in these key markets over the year, the bottom line is that
piracy levels have not come down at all or only marginally, and in some countries
the situation has grown worse.”
As a result of the deficiencies in the copyright regimes of these surveyed
countries/territories, the IIPA reported trade losses and piracy levels for
some copyright industry sectors this year on a country-by-country and industry-by-industry
basis.
For just the 51 countries surveyed in the submission, estimated losses to all
copyright industries totalled $18.4
billion in 2007. On a global basis (that is, in all countries including the
US and including countries not on IIPA’s 301 list), IIPA conservatively
estimated that total losses due to piracy were at least $30-35 billion in 2007,
not counting significant losses due to Internet piracy, for which meaningful
estimates are not yet available.
The key recommendations of the IIPA report included:
Priority Watch List:
The IIPA recommended that the People’s Republic of China remain on the
Priority Watch List. It suggested that engagement with China has been multifaceted
during 2007, including the US government’s commencement of two cases before
the WTO challenging certain of China’s IPR and market access practices
in addition to other ongoing bilateral dialogues and industry-to-government
discussions.
However, it argued that China’s many campaigns and enforcement actions
have in most cases had little deterrent effect in the marketplace, and piracy
rates remain at very high levels.
IIPA also recommended that Russia remain on the Priority Watch List. While
it signed a comprehensive, binding
IPR agreement with the US in 2006, Russia has not yet fully implemented that
agreement, and enforcement continues to be a major deficiency in the Russian
IPR regime.
Russia’s copyright piracy problem remains one of the most serious in
the world, according to the IIPA. Piracy rates for some sectors continued at
over 70% in 2007, resulting in "staggering losses" to the local and
US
industries.
It further suggested that Canada merits inclusion on the Priority Watch List,
announcing that:
"Alone among developed economies in the OECD, Canada has taken no meaningful
steps toward modernizing its copyright law to meet the global minimum standards
of the WIPO Internet Treaties, which it signed more than a decade ago."
"In 2007, the parliamentary leadership and the government, at the highest
levels, acknowledged many of these deficiencies, and the government listed copyright
reform among its top legislative priorities. But these encouraging statements
have not yet evolved into anything more concrete."
IIPA recommended that a further 13 countries be placed on the Priority Watch
List in 2008: Argentina, Canada, Chile, Costa Rica, Egypt, India, Mexico, People’s
Republic of China, Peru, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Thailand, and Ukraine.
Watch List:
The IIPA asked the USTR to place (or maintain) 29 countries/territories on
the Watch List.
New countries which IIPA would like to see added to the Watch List this year
included: Spain, Greece, Sweden, Israel, Lebanon, Turkey, Brunei, Bangladesh,
Nigeria, and Kazakhstan.
Although the IIPA commended Paraguay for its efforts (including cooperation
with industry, plus raids and seizures), few concrete and systemic results in
combating high piracy levels have been achieved. Therefore, it recommended that
the USTR continue to monitor developments in Paraguay under Section 306 of the
Trade Act of 1974.
Out-of-Cycle Reviews:
IIPA requested that USTR later this year conduct out-of-cycle reviews of three
countries to evaluate their progress on the issues identified in the submission:
Italy, Philippines, and Thailand.
IIPA’s “Special Mention” Countries:
Although IIPA is not recommending these countries for placement on a Special
301 list, it urged the USTR to give heightened bilateral attention to eight
additional countries which pose specific problems for US industry. These are
Bulgaria, Germany, Hong Kong, Japan, Jordan, New Zealand, Singapore, and Switzerland.