Hong Kong's government announced yesterday that its budget deficit for the
first half of the fiscal year reached HK$70.8 billion, up 16% on last year's
equivalent HK$60.7 billion. And the deficit isn't the difference between two
large numbers: spending totalled HK$119.4 billion from April to September, while
revenue reached only HK$48.6 billion.
The government's forecast of HK70 billion for the year now seems unattainable,
although the second half normally sees stronger tax inflows. However, Financial
Secretary Antony Leung Kam-chung said the government was confident it could
deal with the growing deficit: "We will try to tackle it in three ways:
to revive the economy, to raise revenue and cut expenditure." The Basic
Law requires the government to keep spending within the limits of revenue to
avoid deficits.
The government has been publicly worrying about how to control the deficit
for months, and has floated various proposals for increasing taxes, all of which
have been met with strong disapproval by business interests and economists.
Better control of expenses seems the preferable route, but the government would
have a fight on its hands if it tried to cut public sector wages, even though
they are widely thought to be too high.
Speaking on Tuesday, Executive Councillor, James Tien announced plans to lobby
the civil service unions for further salary reductions of between 6% and 7%,
but back came the response: 'Another paycut? No way,' from Leung Chau-ting,
the Chairman of the Federation of Civil Service Unions. 'The huge deficit is
not caused by us, and it's unreasonable to ask staff to bear the brunt. One
may argue it is failed governance that caused the deficit problem.'
There was a sharp rise in Hong Kong dollar forward rates yesterday, reflecting
investors' fears have about the currency. Although the government has firmly
ruled out any change to the SAR's dollar peg, there has been persistent speculation
that it will have to go, and many economists areopenly in favour of its demise.
Ratings agency Standard & Poor's lowered its outlook for the Hong Kong dollar
last week, raising the likelihood of a rating downgrade in the next two to three
years.
Hong Kong doesn't face a cash crisis, however: it has financial reserves of
HK$301.7 billion, down from HK$316.5 billion in August.