In its 2003 budget proposals, submitted to Financial Secretary, Antony Leung
Kam-chung on Tuesday, the Hong Kong Society of Accountants proposed, amongst
other measures, a 17% reduction in personal income tax allowances and the introduction
of a surcharge for profits, salaries and property tax payers for two years,
at a rate of 10% based on their actual tax liability.
Entitled 'Balancing the Equation - Achieving Fiscal Equilibrium and a Fairer
Society,' the HKSA's budget submission observed that:
'Whilst the Hong Kong taxation system is relatively competitive vis-a-vis those
of other jurisdictions, there is no room for complacency. Given that some of
the neighbouring jurisdictions have been lowering their tax rates in recent
years, a review of the taxation system in Hong Kong...should be carried out
with a view to enhancing the competitiveness of Hong Kong as an international
financial and business centre.'
Speaking with regard to reducing the country's budget deficit - which the HKSA
predicts will reach HK$65-70 billion this financial year - the accounting body
flagged up a personal allowance reduction and the temporary surcharge as potentially
the most effective ways to tackle the situation. It suggested that the measures
would raise HK$4-5 billion and HK$7.4 billion respectively, if put into practise.
However, speaking to the Hong Kong Standard this week, chairman of the society's
taxation committee, Tim Lui stressed that the surcharge should last no more
than two years, lest the jurisdiction lose its tax-friendly reputation.
'A long-term increase would give overseas investors the perception that Hong
Kong is running against the international trend in increasing its profit tax
levels. This would hamper investor confidence and the image of Hong Kong,'
he told the newspaper, adding:
'If the economy is then turned around, the government could accordingly review
its circumstances or remove the surcharge.'
In the long-term, the HKSA also recommended the introduction of a goods and
services tax, or some other form of consumption tax, and an increase in the
resources and efforts directed towards conducting tax investigations and audits.