The government of Gibraltar has welcomed a judgment by the European Court of
Justice which backed the European Commission's decision against tax cuts in
the Azores, a Portuguese dependency.
In the Azores case the Court had to determine the principles that apply in deciding
whether a tax regime is in breach of state aid rules on grounds of Regional
Selectivity.
According to Gibraltar, the ECJ's decision "fully vindicates" its
own arguments before the Court as to why it is entitled to have a separate and
different tax regime to that of the UK.
"The judgment confirms that the principles to be applied in deciding this
issue, are the very principles upon which the Gibraltar Government’s case
is based and pleaded," a government statement argued.
"The Government is encouraged, in particular, by the fact that at para.68
of the judgment, the Court sets out the principles to be applied by upholding
the UK Government’s arguments. Those arguments are the same ones as both
the Gibraltar and UK Governments are making in the Gibraltar case. This judgment
is therefore extremely helpful to our case," the statement added.
Gibraltar has been attempting to overhaul its company taxation system by introducing
a new regime which will replace the mainstream 35% corporate tax and tax-exempt
company forms with a payroll tax and a business property occupation tax, both
of which will be capped at 15% of profit.
However, this plan has been blocked by the EU’s decision that the jurisdiction
effectively constitutes part of the UK, and therefore such a tax regime would
breach EU state aid rules.