Last week Digicel Group Ltd, a fast growing wireless telecommunications operator
in the Caribbean and Central America, issued a claim in the English High Court
against Cable and Wireless plc and various of its subsidiaries, seeking multi-million
pound damages.
Digicel claims that C&W had engaged in illegal behaviour by impeding and
delaying Digicel’s entry into various telecommunications markets in the
English-speaking Caribbean. Digicel claims that it has been the victim of a
co-ordinated effort on C&W’s part to prevent and delay Digicel launching
competing mobile telephone networks in St Lucia, St Vincent & the Grenadines,
Grenada, Barbados, the Cayman Islands, Trinidad & Tobago and the Turks and
Caicos Islands.
The suit alleges that obstructions and delays by C&W, between 2002 and
2006, have resulted in substantial damages and as a result Digicel’s claim
covers:
- Losses of revenue, profits and market share;
- Restitutionary damages from C&W for the gains and benefits made by
C&W as a result of its unlawful conduct; and
- Exemplary damages (compensation in excess of actual damages) and interest.
The damages sought by Digicel would amount to several hundreds of millions
of pounds, said the company. It is expected that the claim will come to the
High Court in 2008.
Commenting on the claim Denis O’Brien, Chairman of Digicel said; “We
are extremely frustrated with the continual illegal obstructions that we have
encountered from C&W. We believe that a successful claim will not only compensate
Digicel for the losses it has suffered but also that it will put an end to the
anti-competitive practices of C&W. This will be of undoubted benefit to
all network operators and more importantly all mobile users in the Caribbean.”
Cable and Wireless held a telecommunications monopoly in most of the Caribbean
territories in which Digicel now operates. Whether due to rearguard action on
the part of C&W or dilatory behaviour by local governments, the liberalization
process - so important to territories struggling to compete in a globalized
economy - has been slow and challenging for new entrants. Even when new licenses
have been issued, Digicel complains that C&W has been uncooperative during
the interconnection process needed to hook up new providers to existing infrastructure.
Cable & Wireless said on Friday that it had received a claim but said
it would vigorously defend itself: "We don't believe it has any foundation,"
said a spokesman.