There
seems to be no improvement in the fortunes of the
beleagured Cyprus Stock Exchange (CSE). Last week
Tax-news.com reported that a Greek stock exchange
expert, Demetris Tsimbanoulis, had been drafted in
to spend 100 days examining Cyprus' stock exchange
practices and operations, but news that a positive
action plan could soon be on its way seems to have
done little to quell investor anxiety. Earlier this
week, a state of panic gripped the CSE as investors
rushed in droves to sell their shares, and at the
same time the Chairman of Investors Association
PASEHA issued an attack against stockbrokers and the
Securities and Exchange Commission, which he claimed
did nothing to reveal discrepancies and illegalities
that have led to the CSE's current sorry state.
The rush
to sell shares this week caused a major fall in the
index, which plummeted to its lowest level this year.
It was hoped that the listing of Bank of Cyprus in
Athens last week would boost the CSE, but according
to stockbroker Costas Anastasiades, the fact that
Bank of Cyprus shares did not rise to a level matching
Cypriot investors expectations meant that many
frustrated investors rushed to sell their stakes in
the Bank of Cyprus. He said many investors decided
to sell when they realised there would be no short-term
gains from the banks listing in Athens, adding
that the short-term approach to investment was still
prevalent among Cypriot investors.
This
panic-selling does little to help the CSE achieve
some kind of stability. Marios Mavrides, an analyst
and Chairman of the Business Management department
at Cyprus College said: 'it is wrong to link the CSE
to the Greek market because the two Stock Exchanges
continue to be influenced by different factors.....
panic behaviour on the floor was unreasonable and
very dangerous.'
It is
the stockbrokers, rather than the investors, who are
being blamed for this week's panic. They have also
been chastised this week by PASEHA Chairman Alkis
Argyrides for ruling the CSE. He said that it is the
stockbrokers who can pull the strings and determine
price and index levels. Mr Argyrides claims that stockbrokers
carry out transactions without in any way being controlled,
they make phantom sales and carry out sale and purchase
transactions in the name of investors, who are indebted
to them. He has also accused the Securities and Exchange
Commission (SEC) and CSE Council of not carrying out
all the necessary controls, despite the fact that
PASEHA had submitted specific complaints requiring
investigation.
However,
SEC Chairman Andreas Charalambous has hit back by
saying no evidence of discrepancies and illegalities
has ever been submitted to the SEC. He said there
was always a person checking daily transactions on
the CSE as much as possible, adding that
general and vague complaints are not enough.
However,
the Greek expert appointed by the Cyprus government
seems to have faith in the CSE. Commencing his three-month
long stint to try and find a cure for the ailing exchange,
he said there are no stock markets without problems
and room for improvement, no matter how modern and
up-to-date they are.