The CFA Institute and the National Investor Relations Institute will this week
launch a set of "best practice guidelines" designed to clarify the
situation with regard to paid research commissioned by US firms.
Following a settlement reached between regulators and Wall Street investment
banks in late 2003 which imposed many restrictions on firms offering both banking
and research services, several of the institutions in question decided to close
down or spin off their research departments, leaving some of the smaller listed
firms in the United States under the radar in terms of attracting the attention
of investors.
As a result, many such firms are considering paying for their own research,
a move which the CFA Institute and National Investor Relations Institute warned
is potentially fraught with danger.
Under the new guidelines issued by the trade groups in order to help firms
avoid regulatory pitfalls, analysts must be paid in cash before the reports
are written, and must disclose the fact that they are being compensated by the
company, in addition to any other ties that they have with it, in their report.
In addition, companies must agree not to retaliate against brokerages and analysts
who offer negative opinions regarding their financial and governance situation.
Analysts will also be prevented from letting companies review recommendations
in advance.
Although, according to an Associated Press report, the CFA Institute and the
NIRI acknowledged last week that they have little power to enforce the guidelines,
they warned that:
"Members of each organization should be aware that violations might result
in disciplinary actions."