Leadership of the Caribbean Financial Action Task Force has passed from Alfred
Sears, Bahamas Attorney General and Minister of Education, to Sir Ronald Sanders,
Chief Foreign Affairs Representative with Ministerial Rank and High Commissioner
for Antigua & Barbuda to the United Kingdom.
The Caribbean Financial Action Task Force (CFATF) is an organisation of thirty
states of the Caribbean Basin, loosely modelled on the FATF (comprised of OECD
members) which have agreed to implement common countermeasures to address the
problem of criminal money laundering and the financing of terrorism. The CFATF
Secretariat is hosted by the Government of Trinidad & Tobago.
Relinquishing his role as CFATF Chairman, Minister Sears said it was imperative
that The Bahamas continue its lead in regard to being at the forefront of international
standards in anti-money laundering efforts and combating the financing of terrorists.
Specifically, ”..we must ensure that our legislation keeps track of the
changing typologies used by money launderers and persons who finance terrorists
acts. We must continue to interact meaningfully with our international partners
and encourage capacity building.”
During his tenure as President, Mr. Sears actively promoted a forum on money
laundering under the auspices of the United Nations, hopefully to produce a
UN Convention on Money Laundering. It is anticipated that such a Convention
would allow the establishment of international standards of money laundering
that would be applied equally to all nations. Importantly, this would allow
all member countries of the UN the right to participate in the making of the
rules and ensure the even application of such.
Highlights of his chairmanship included the promotion of enhanced international
cooperation between CFATF members and their international counterparts and the
provision of technical assistance. On the latter, Minister Sears points out
that this is based on the concept that “we live in an interdependent world
and in order to defend our respective sovereign space, we need to ensure that
every area of the world has adequate capacity to withstand the menace of money
laundering and financing terrorism.”
The feisty Sir Ronald may bring a more confrontational tone to the CFATF. Just
last month he led a group of eight nations at the WTO headquarters in Geneva
in an attempt to persuade the organisation not to adopt recent OECD and FATF
directives. Sir Ronald expressed concern at the cost that smaller jurisdictions
are paying to comply with these directives, and alarm at the way in which the
larger economies are dominating the decision making process in international
financial bodies such as the WTO and OECD.
"The world has entered a dangerous phase, it is one in which, despite the international
problems that confront the global community and the logic that such international
problems demand international solutions, a number of larger and more powerful
states have abrogated to themselves the task of making rules and imposing them
on others through either threat, or the impositions, of sanctions", Sanders
told the Committee on Trade in Financial Services.
"The sovereign right of states to regulate and manage their crucial financial
services sector is being challenged continually by some countries who appear
to have usurped the role of international organizations such as the WTO in global
governance", Sir Ronald continued, stating that these countries had "no legitimacy"
to act in such a way.
Sanders argued that the protectionism of the financial sectors of the larger
countries was harmful to non-members of the two organisations, and attacked
the "coercive methods they have adopted (which) challenge a basic tenet of the
WTO - namely multilateralism, which includes Most Favoured Nation treatment
as well as open consultation between WTO members".
The document presented to the Committee by Sir Ronald proposed to "promote
the greater inclusiveness of small states in the process of formulating these
standards by placing them under the umbrella of the WTO instead of in the bosom
of plurilateral organizations with limited membership." It continued: "We propose
that the inclusiveness and international legitimacy of financial standards,
universally negotiated and universally applied, can be accomplished best through
the provisions related to Domestic Regulation under Article VI of the GATS".
Sir Ronald has also been to the fore in attacking the attempts of the US to
throttle small offshore jurisdictions which have been making a living out of
providing gambling sites to US citizens, obtaining permission from the WTO to
bring a complaint against the US.
The US Congress is close to passing a bill which would criminalise such activities,
but the government of Antigua and Barbuda recently announced that it had filed
its first submission to the World Trade Organisation (WTO) Disputes Panel.
"We are pleased that our case is proceeding according to the schedule set by
the panel," said Sir Ronald. "We look forward to hearing the response of
the United States. As a small country with very little in the way of viable
exports, the gaming industry represents a vital area of our development of electronic
commerce for a global market. We believe very strongly in our case under the
law."
Antigua and Barbuda is basing its claim on the WTO's General Agreement on Trade
in Services (GATS). The government is arguing that the US is violating its commitment
to fellow WTO members under GATS by prohibiting the provision of cross-border
gambling and betting services.
Sir Ronald and his Antiguan materfamilias aren't just trouble-makers. Earlier
this year, Antigua and Barbuda received the highest possible praise from the
Caribbean Financial Action Task Force over its anti-money laundering policies.
A CFATF report concluded that the legislative framework implemented by the jurisdiction
is in total compliance with international standards in addition to being properly
enforced. In order to gain this distinction, 40 FATF conditions had to be satisfied,
plus 19 CFATF rules and 25 FATF Non-co-operative countries and territories'
criteria.
Sir Ronald pointed out that the process of transforming the culture of compliance
was painful, especially given the territory's reputation as a haven for dirty
money in the 1990s. As a consequence many banks left the country due to the
increase scrutiny they were facing, and the jurisdiction now has only 15 banks
compared with over 60 in the mid 1990s. However, Sanders feels that the nation
is the better for it, and the legislation introduced has made income from the
banking sector far more stable.
"That means we'll keep these businesses longer, we'll get the revenue from
them longer, employment will continue longer. With dirty money, either the law
catches up with them or they collapse themselves, and there's no predictability."
he affirmed.