Ireland’s period as the ‘Celtic Tiger’ of Europe has seen its
economic growth soar, hastening the Republic’s rise from being one of the
poorest countries in Europe to one of the wealthiest.
The rise in the fortunes of the Irish economy from the mid 1990s to the present
day (via a few bumps in the road) can be attributed to many factors, including
the well-educated and English speaking workforce, the government’s keen
interest and investment in developing the economy, and cooperation between the
government, employers, and unions.
The key drivers of economic growth in Ireland in the past decade and a half,
though, must be recognised as the Republic’s membership of the EU (with
all of the aid and trade benefits that come with such a position), the government’s
targeting of foreign direct investment as one of its main priorities, and last
but by no means least, the decision to reduce the corporate tax rate to 12.5%
(and until recent years, 10% in various locations, such as the International
Financial Services Centre).
All of these factors have, for the most part, combined to ensure Ireland’s
position as the resident EU success story. However, there are now fears that
the tiger may be losing its teeth for good, a fate that the Irish authorities
are understandably keen to avoid.
In the light of the general economic malaise currently being felt worldwide,
the Irish government’s recent announcement that its finances are in worse
shape than had previously been thought does not come as much of a surprise.
At the end of July, the Irish authorities predicted that whole year tax receipts
would fall below budget estimates by around EUR3bn; but new figures for the
year to the end of August suggested that the shortfall is likely to be far more
substantial, in the region of EUR5bn. Declining VAT revenues as a result of
weaker consumer spending, and lower capital gains tax revenue, due to the ailing
property market are thought to be contributing to the budget shortfall.
Facing a deteriorating economic climate and falling tax revenues, the Irish
government subsequently announced that it would bring forward the date of this
year's budget announcement from December to October, meaning that Finance Minister
Brian Lenihan will now announce the budget on October 14. The government hopes
that such a decisive move will "give clarity and confidence to investors
and taxpayers alike," and provide a sound basis for economic recovery.
"The emerging scale of the economic and fiscal and environmental challenges
now facing the country require that the government take the necessary decisions
to ensure stability in the public finances, while giving firm support for those
aspects of the economy which are continuing to perform strongly, and ensuring
that Ireland benefits as early and as fully as possible from improved international
economic conditions," it stated.
"Taking decisive action now is critical to our future sustainable growth,"
commented Lenihan, observing that: "We are better placed than most economies
to meet the challenges ahead with our low debt rate, our educated and young
workforce, and our low tax environment for workers and business."
So, what are the contributing factors to this sudden fall from grace, aside
from the general economic situation?
Some commentators point to relatively poor infrastructure (outside of Dublin),
rising inflation, and high public expenditure, but it is surely the entry of
several Eastern European ‘new kids on the block’ to the European
Union that has done the Celtic Tiger the most damage, attracting investment
away from Ireland with the promise of lower wages, and in the case of 2007 EU
entrant Bulgaria, a planned 10% flat tax. Estonia is another frequently cited
example of successful flat tax reforms, and Slovakia and Romania are also among
the flat tax countries now nipping at Ireland’s heels, not to mention
Cyprus, which also has a rock-bottom 10% tax rate.
Aside from the initiatives aimed at "encouraging investment and activity
and deepening Ireland’s competitiveness" that the Irish authorities
assure the population are to be announced in the coming weeks and months, and
tax changes to be unveiled in the 2009 budget next month that are already "well
advanced", what should the government do in order to reassert the jurisdiction’s
position as Europe’s big cat?
In its economic assessment of the Republic earlier this year, the Organisation
for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) highlighted the need to raise
productivity growth as a key long-term challenge to the Irish economy, and argued
that wage moderation is needed to avoid a weakening of export performance. In
commenting on the Republic's fiscal position, the OECD further noted that the
rate of public spending needs to slow, and that it is important not to lock-in
expensive spending commitments.
Businesses located in the RoI, meanwhile, stress the importance of maintaining
the low corporate tax rate for which Ireland has become noted, and which, if
no longer unique to the country, or even the most attractive rate going, is
still significantly lower than many of the other ‘old’ EU members.
This position was highlighted by Intel's Vice-President of Finance and Enterprise
and Director of Global Tax and Trade, Nanci Palmintere, when she delivered the
keynote speech at the 17th Annual Tax Research Network (TRN) Conference, held
at the National University of Ireland, Galway (NUI Galway) last week.
Addressing delegates on the subject of ‘Tax and Business Aspects of
Site Selection’, Ms Palmintere explained that although other factors come
into play when multinationals consider where to locate their operations, such
as the presence of a skilled workforce, transport infrastructure, land availability,
and business costs, tax levels are a key consideration. Warning the Irish authorities
against any form of tax harmonisation, she further observed that: "There
needs to be consistency and transparency in the operating conditions."
Perhaps, overall, the Irish need not be too worried. Surely they have to apply
the brakes to the runaway public spending which seemed so easy to finance during
the golden years, but the usps of low taxation and a well-educated, English-speaking
work-force will remain a magnet for US companies seeking to set up European
HQs. The only alternative, the UK, is entering a long period of over-taxed economic
difficulty. Far from attracting new investment, the UK government seems powerless
to stop a gradual drift of companies across the Irish Sea and in the wrong direction.
One recent refugee from the Treasury's clammy embrace, pharmaceutical FTSE100
Shire Group said last month that it was very happy in Ireland and had no intention
whatsoever of returning to the UK.