AdMart, the leading
Hong Kong online and phone retailer, closed on Tuesday, adding
to the general gloom about the prospects for local 'dotcoms'.
The company, owned by Jimmy Lai, the Hong Kong media magnate,
is expected to lay off most of its nearly 350 employees by next
month.
The AdMart website
was carrying a sad message by the end of the week:
'Thank you for visiting
the adM@rt/ezVan website. We would like to thank you for your
patronage and inform you that adM@rt/ezVan has ceased operations
in Hong Kong as of December 11, 2000. We will no longer be providing
products and services as of that day. We began this business based
on the belief that we could bring customers to buy traditional
retail goods online, and because of AdM@rt/ezVan, consumers in
Hong Kong have enjoyed significant improvement in price, selection
and service as retailers across the industry worked to compete
with the adM@rt/ezVan promise.
'However, we did
not achieve the results we had hoped. Acknowledging this, we have
made the decision to cease operation in this market. All product
warranties will be honored, and pre-paid orders will be reimbursed.
If you need further information about a purchase or product warranty,
please telephone 3182-2082 or email webmaster@admart.com.hk.
Thank you very much for your support.'
This sticky end for AdMart is not really a surprise. Earlier this
year Jimmy Lai admitted he was losing $10m a month, although the
company's estimate at one point was (only) $4m a month. And he
has been open about where the blame lies: "I'm in deep shit,"
he said. "Maybe it's a conspiracy. But not in the sense that
it's secret. It's not. They're out to crush me. It is like I'm
trespassing. In Hong Kong, you just don't do that. I guess that's
why this feels like a personal vendetta."
It's an open secret
that Lai's nemesis is Li Ka-shing, chief of the Cheung Kong and
Hutchison Whampoa groups. "You can call Li names; he does
nothing," said a prominent media person. "But you put
your finger in his pocket and he'll crush you. Jimmy is just in
Li's territory, and Li will crush him."
The failure of AdMart
follows the closure of most of the other web businesses controlled
by media magnate Jimmy Lai's Next Media group. Lai may have been
his own worst enemy. The ex-textile trader was successful at first,
founding Giordano, the clothing chain that became an Asia-wide
brand, then challenging Hong Kong's powerful media moguls in 1995
with his publishing phenomenon, Apple Daily newspaper. But then
he stuck his neck out:fter the Tiananmen crackdown, selling Giordano
T-shirts carrying photos of the student leaders; later he memorably
called former Chinese premier Li Peng "the son of a turtle's
egg with zero IQ."
It was no surprise
after that when Beijing refused to allow Giordano stores on the
mainland, and Lai had to sell the company. Then Li's Hutchison
declared war on AdMart by ordering its subsidiaries to pull advertisements
from his Apple Daily newspaper. Apple advertising manager Peter
Kuo also claims that eight property developers, including industry
giants Henderson, Sun Hung Kai and Sino Land, pulled their ads
for three months, starting in August. "It really seems like
they made this agreement to hold out advertising from us for three
months," he says. We think he's orchestrating this whole
thing through intermediaries."
A month ago Lai said
about AdMart's travail: "This won't put me out of business
or bankrupt me. I'd pull the plug before that happened. I just
don't think I'll have to." Let's hope he was right.